© 2017 All Rights Reserved. Do not distribute or repurpose this work without written permission from the copyright holder(s).
Printed from https://www.damninteresting.com/fire-and-dice/?utm_source=DamnInteresting
Downstairs in the casino, little remained of the MGM Grand Hotel’s former glory. In the early morning hours of 21 November 1980, a fire had broken out in the Las Vegas landmark, ripping through the lounge in an explosive wave that instantly killed everyone in the area. Bodies sat frozen in front of what had once been slot machines, now no more than blackened pillars jutting upward from a flow of melted slag along the floor. The room’s plastic and chrome-plated decor, it turned out, had been as much a facade as its promises of riches.
Fortunately, the Clark County Fire Department had responded immediately, and the blaze never spread beyond the first floor. From where David Demers and his fire investigation team stood on the 23rd floor, no one would have even felt the temperature rise. Why, then, were they surrounded by corpses?
When the MGM Grand Hotel and Casino first opened in 1973, it was the largest hotel in the world, with advertisements claiming more square footage than the Empire State Building. The first floor boasted a movie theater, two stages, and five restaurants, yet these were no more than satellites to the main attraction: a casino the size of three football fields. The hotel’s 26 floors stretched into the sky as a bold declaration of not only wealth, but vitality. Las Vegas had beaten back the desert, and its newest crown jewel seemed impossible to tarnish.
Unfortunately, when the fire struck seven years later, the MGM Grand would live up to its record-setting reputation. By the end of the day, 85 people would lose their lives and approximately 700 would be injured, including 14 firefighters who had to be hospitalized. It was the deadliest hotel fire in the nation since the introduction of modern fire safety codes in the 1940s.
Though not especially onerous, the codes at that time were complex and open to interpretation. One rule, for example, stated that sprinklers must be installed in all public areas, but another exempted areas expected to be occupied 24 hours a day, on the theory that someone would always be there to put out a fire. Smoke detectors were a given, but commercial builders could install them inside the ventilation system rather than in each individual room for efficiency’s sake—many builders preferred this option because it placed the detectors out of sight, where they could not detract from the aesthetics. Buildings underwent a relatively exhaustive list of safety checks to pass final inspection, but once open to the public, reassessment was minimal, no matter how many years had passed.
Regulations also varied state to state. Some, like Connecticut, had banned highly flammable building materials altogether. Others, like Nevada, operated on the philosophy that treatment was easier than prevention, and required only the emergency stairwells to be sealed with smoke-proof, fire-rated materials.
The builders of the MGM Grand in particular seemed eager to save money wherever possible. Construction had gone on longer than expected, and inspectors had given the hotel a failing grade multiple times as it neared completion. It was a contractor, in fact, who brought up the 24-hour exemption for sprinklers; only after they pointed it out to the fire marshal’s office did the fire marshal begrudgingly agree that most of the hotel did not legally require sprinklers after all.
Once the resort finally opened, however, it boomed. The opening weekend featured performers Cary Grant and Gregory Peck, among others, and Dean Martin’s famous Friar’s Club roasts took place there each year. On the weekend of the fire, all 2,000 guest rooms were sold out, packed with a typical array of traveling families and partying bachelorettes, touring performers and sightseeing retirees. Many had booked their rooms on relatively short notice, after the large computer industry trade show known as COMDEX changed locations to another venue at the last moment.
For the investigators who examined the hotel in the days following the tragedy, however, it was the distribution of bodies, rather than their number, that was most perplexing. Guest rooms began on the fifth floor, and the firefighters’ ladders had been able to reach windows as high as the ninth. Above that, the victims’ lives should have depended mostly on their wits and perhaps how much they’d had to drink the night before. Logic would suggest a distribution favoring the lowest and highest floors, close to escape points on the streets below and the roof above, with those in the unlucky middle being farthest from the exits.
Instead, only one person between the 5th and 18th floors had died. Above that, the death toll spiked dramatically, peaking with 14 bodies on the 23rd floor. Even on the top two floors, just steps from safety, no fewer than eight people had perished.
Overwhelmed by the magnitude and complexity of the situation, the Clark County Fire Department requested assistance from both the United States Fire Administration and the National Fire Protection Association, where David Demers was the manager of the Fire Investigation Division. Now it was their job to figure out exactly what had happened, from the moment the fire began all the way until the last victim died from complications almost a week later.
The fire’s origin, at least, was easy to identify: it had begun inside the wall of The Deli, a 24-hour casual eating area just beyond the main showroom. Sometime after the original construction of the hotel, a new refrigerated pastry display case had been installed, and the copper pipes of its compressor had been run through the same section of wall as the electrical conduit for the room. This was undoubtedly a bad idea, but not inherently destructive in itself.
The machine had been improperly secured, and vibrated slightly from the day it was installed. Over time, these vibrations caused the pipes to shift sideways until they touched the aluminum conduit, which had also been improperly installed with no ground wire. The copper ate away at the aluminum in a process known as galvanic corrosion—the same electrochemical process that allows batteries to work. Continued vibration then wore through the wire insulation. The entire process took several years, but the copper eventually came in direct contact with the electrified wires, heating the pipes “to the point of glowing metal,” according to the investigation team’s official report.
With minimal oxygen inside the wall, the fire smoldered and spread for an unknown period of time. The Barrymore restaurant next door was not a 24-hour facility, and had fate sent the flames in that direction, sprinklers would have quickly doused them with no serious harm done. Instead, the fire broke through into The Deli just before 7:00 a.m. Unfortunately, lacking business in recent years, The Deli had begun closing overnight. No one was there.
A hotel employee named Tim Connor happened to take a shortcut through the empty restaurant at 7:13 a.m. and was horrified to discover “a sheet of flames running from the top of the counter to the ceiling.” The fire report noted that from Connor’s vantage point, he could only have seen one corner of the much larger fire already in progress—but regardless of size, he couldn’t put it out. The Deli’s fire extinguisher was missing.
Connor called security from a phone on the wall, just before a wave of heat and smoke knocked him to the ground “like a sea in a wind tunnel.” He barely managed to scramble along the floor out of the restaurant.
The Barrymore had been properly equipped with both an extinguisher and a wall-mounted fire hose, but by the time Connor and other responding employees dragged them around to the source of the fire, it was too late. Flames had reached the ceiling tiles, which were attached with an especially flammable adhesive that even the Nevada building code had banned from commercial use three years earlier. The fire began to spread above the men’s heads much more rapidly, between 5 and 10 feet per second. Realizing they would soon be trapped, they fled back into the casino, slamming the thick double doors behind them and shouting a warning to everyone in their path. Less than six minutes had passed since Connor had discovered the fire.
The closed doors slowed the flames for a few critical moments in the foyer between the restaurants and the casino, but the added time came at a price. Fire traveling along a floor or other interior furnishings will generally spread in a predictable path from one item to the next, depending on the fuel available to consume—a table next to a couch does not burn until most of the couch is alight, for example. But fire in a ceiling or upper wall burns more thinly and evenly, due to the uniform surface, and usually the flames are not large enough to reach flammable items below. Instead, the room temperature steadily rises until a phenomenon known as “flashover” occurs, when all of the combustible material along the floor reaches its spontaneous ignition point at the same moment.
In the small but lavishly furnished foyer, the resulting explosion blew off the doors to the casino entirely, flooding the room with fresh oxygen and extending the fireball into the lounge. Here, too, the ceiling tiles had been attached with the same highly flammable adhesive, which experts estimate the fire consumed at 15 to 19 feet per second. Those who had not yet heard or obeyed the shouts for evacuation died instantly.
Fortunately, local firefighters reached the scene within just two minutes of the first call and valiantly fought back the flames to their source. Sprinklers in other sections of the hotel triggered, containing the fire to the areas already engulfed. Within less than an hour, the blaze was under control. For the guests still inside the hotel, however, the ordeal was far from over.
Contrary to building codes, the elevator doors had not been tightly sealed on any level of the hotel, sometimes leaving a gap as large as 3/4 of an inch. Waves of heat nearing 10,000º F (5,540º C) entered the elevator shafts near the casino. Within minutes, the stainless steel cables melted, plummeting the elevators past the inferno and into the basement. Had any of the five guests inside the elevators survived the fall, their luck didn’t gain them much; moments later, the counterweights—no longer attached to anything—also fell and crushed the cars beneath them.
One elevator did not fall, but its four occupants died from asphyxiation after it became stuck on the 20th floor. Normal operation would have required the elevator cars to open their doors and cease operation as soon as a fire alarm tripped in the building, but the unsightly smoke detectors supposedly “hidden” inside the ventilation system had never been installed at all. The main alarm could be activated from the security office, but neither of the two employees on duty did so before running to the aid of evacuating guests.
Most of those guests were still upstairs, unaware of the chaos going on below. Some died in their sleep because the fan coil units in the guest rooms ran continuously, pumping smoke in from the hallway. Designed to be vented into a vertical air shaft leading outside, the units in the MGM Grand had been connected to interior air sources for unknown reasons. Others woke to the sounds of shouts or the sirens on the street below, but found the halls already impassable.
Even those who made it to the exits were not yet in the clear. Of the six emergency stairwells, the supposedly fire-rated materials failed in four, and smoke flowed freely into them almost as soon as the fire began. In addition, all of the doors leading into the stairwells were set to automatically lock from the inside. With the ground floor inaccessible, many evacuees found themselves trapped, forced to flee upward as many as 20 flights of stairs in thick smoke before they reached the safety of the roof.
“Smoke entered the wall spaces indiscriminately,” according to Demers’ report, and the increasing pressure from below forced it through any available opening. Dark soot would later be found surrounding the shower heads and faucet fixtures in many of the bathrooms. One man, who was rescued from his smoke-filled room by firefighters after more than an hour, said he and his coworkers had thrown chairs through their hotel window to vent the room as best they could, and then lay on the floor “with our noses in the corners saying Hail Marys.”
Yet that hadn’t been everyone’s experience. Smoke poured into the hallways each time the stairwell doors opened, but otherwise their fireproofing failed only at the bottom levels. Thousands of guests between the fifth and 18th floors managed to navigate the halls until they reached one of the two good staircases. Investigators found minimal smoke damage on those floors—despite the floors suffering the same defects of elevator doors with gaps and unvented fan coils. The smoke on the uppermost floors had come from somewhere else. This anomaly finally led investigators to the most appalling failure in the hotel’s construction.
Commercial ventilation systems require “fire dampers” at regular intervals—a large metal panel held open by a piece known as a fusible link. The link has a low melting point, which breaks in the heat of a fire and slams the trap door shut to prevent smoke from circulating into the ventilation system. In the MGM Grand, all of the fire dampers on the lower levels had been improperly installed, and the ones over the casino in particular had been permanently bolted open by workers who either didn’t know their purpose or simply found them inconvenient. The links melted, but the dampers stayed open.
Once the smoke had passed through the ductwork, it entered a large empty circulation space known as an air plenum. Or at least, it should have been empty—the plenum above the casino in the MGM Grand contained hundreds of miles’ worth of electrical wiring, as well as several drain pipes up to a foot across. Instead of traditional PVC, these were made of another type of plastic known as ABS. It was less expensive and easier to install, but produced cyanide gas when burned. The wire insulation also melted to produce its own toxic gases.
At the top of the plenum, two seismic joints acted as chimneys to shunt the smoke upward to the top floors. Meant to account for the natural expansion and contraction of the building in changing temperatures, the vertical one-foot gaps should not have been open to the ventilation system, but they were. The heated pressure from below sent smoke rocketing past the lower floors to the top of the hotel, where open air vents fed directly into the hallways and rooms. Combustible material in the casino itself, nearly all of which was made of plastic, added to the toxic gases in the plenum. Foam padding inside faux leather stools, decorative moldings with wood grain printed on them, “crystal” chandeliers that weighed only a few pounds, slot machines full of chips: as it always had, the money went up in smoke.
Though repairs totaled over $50 million dollars, it took just seven months before the MGM Grand was again open for business, with the majority of the structure left unchanged. Even after the property was sold to Bally Manufacturing several years later, the massive towers were updated rather than replaced, and they are still part of the Bally’s Las Vegas casino to this day. The legal damages, however, would not be paid off so quickly. Between the insecure pastry case, ungrounded conduit, lack of sprinklers, missing fire extinguishers, flammable ceiling tiles, bolted fire dampers, unsealed staircases, impractical locks, malfunctioning elevators, missing smoke detectors, open seismic joints, unvented fan coils, and general lack of any fire evacuation training among the staff, the plaintiffs had plenty of grievances.
Over the next six years, the Clark County Court system fielded 1,327 lawsuits related to the fire, naming 118 different defendants and generating around 4 million pages of documents. The owners of the MGM Grand knew their liability insurance would be insufficient, so they negotiated an entirely new insurance product with their provider called “loss mitigation” or “retroactive” underwriting. The deal cost them $40 million—a fraction of the expected damages from the lawsuits—which the insurance company accepted on the premise that litigation would take years. They gambled that they could invest the smaller payment in the meantime and still come out ahead. (They lost. The guilty rulings came so quickly that the insurance company refused to pay the retroactive policy, setting off another entire round of litigation with the MGM Grand completely separate from the victims’ cases.) The first of its kind, this type of policy would spread in popularity over the next twenty years, and eventually play a large role in another set of failed wagers—the housing foreclosure crisis in the early 2000s.
The settlements to the MGM Grand fire victims totaled $223 million, more than half of which came from building contractors who had provided substandard materials, installation, or both. The installers of the highly flammable and banned ceiling adhesive took one of the biggest hits. It was later reported that, had the owners chosen to install sprinklers in The Deli and other unprotected areas when the hotel was built, it would have added just $192,000 to the total construction budget of $106 million.
The one thing that did not fail was the courage of the people on the scene that morning. Two firefighters on vacation from Illinois happened to be getting coffee near The Deli when they heard the first shouts; they remained in the building to help evacuate other guests. One security guard dragged two unconscious patrons out of the hotel, while an unnamed advertising executive from Pittsburgh carried another elderly guest down 21 flights of stairs to safety. Construction workers used their scaffolding to reach windows the fire trucks could not, while nine helicopters flew in from nearby Nellis Air Force base to rescue nearly 300 people from the roof. Other hotels around the city provided more than 1,500 spare rooms, and many strangers offered to share theirs.
Even the COMDEX attendees who had narrowly avoided being at the scene themselves provided aid. By 9:30 a.m., while victims were still being rescued above, Commodore Business Machines had already rolled their entire booth down the street to the east wing of the MGM. They used their new OZ list-management product to track the names, addresses, and whereabouts of survivors, and coordinated with the makers of a new large-character printer to create hourly, up-to-date lists in oversized fonts that workers and volunteers could read from a distance.
One reason COMDEX volunteers responded so quickly is that they heard the news before almost anyone else. A handful of attendees had ended up as guests at the MGM Grand despite the conference’s relocation, when rooms at their new venue sold out. Eight perished in the fire, but others began straggling into the convention hall as soon as they escaped because they didn’t know where else to go. Men in three-piece suits comforted their coworkers in soot-covered sleepwear while the room of several thousand attendees held a moment of silence for the tragedy. Many had already been setting up for another day of business when the fireball tore through the neighboring hotel—had their convention taken place on the first floor of the MGM Grand, as originally intended, the death toll could have been exponentially higher.
As it was, only 18 people were killed by the initial explosion. The rest of the 85 dead were victims of shortcuts, poor planning, and a gambler’s sense of invincibility that Las Vegas had banked on for generations. Today, the MGM Grand fire is credited for the major overhaul of building codes and safety regulations that occurred soon after—but in fact, it wasn’t until a second Las Vegas hotel fire a month later, this time claiming eight victims at a Hilton, that lawmakers took the issue seriously. If the two events hadn’t occurred so close to one another, there’s no telling how many years it would have been before the city admitted it was on a losing streak with their visitors’ lives.
© 2017 All Rights Reserved. Do not distribute or repurpose this work without written permission from the copyright holder(s).
Printed from https://www.damninteresting.com/fire-and-dice/?utm_source=DamnInteresting
Since you enjoyed our work enough to print it out, and read it clear to the end, would you consider donating a few dollars at https://www.damninteresting.com/donate ?
1st? Great article, DI as always
Wow! Imagine how much worse things would have been if the fire had started at 7 pm instead! the casino floor would have been packed, the death toll would have skyrocketed. Damn interesting indeed!
Fantastic article! Would love to know more about the litigation between MGM and the insurance company (mentioned in the parenthetical)!
I’m not sure if the timing on publishing this is fortunate or unfortunate, given the fire in London today.
As always an interesting article.
You could have perhaps made it interesting and USEFUL if you had elaborated on – The rest of the 85 dead were victims of shortcuts, poor planning, and a gambler’s sense of invincibility that Las Vegas had banked on for generations.
What short cuts, what poor planning etc and why it lead to their dooms.
DI article as always and frighteningly eerie being published a day before the Grenfell Tower disaster.
A few inaccuracies but a good article.
The space above a ceiling can serve as a return air plenum and is allowed to have piping and wiring. The wiring insulation has to be plenum rated, made of material that does not put off much smoke or toxic fumes when it burns. If the wiring is enclosed in conduit it does not have to be plenum rated.
So a plenum isn’t necessarily supposed to be empty.
VG, I think you misunderstood. (I could be wrong.)
The reference to “shortcuts and poor planning” was not to the guests’ methods of escape, but to the lazy construction decisions.
Ben – Sharp eye! I have spent a few days trying to locate my original source for that information, and unfortunately I can’t. But of course the codes back in 1980 were not the same as they are today, nor were they the same in Nevada compared to other states. The MGM Grand fire specifically ushered in changes to the code that were not there before. Here you can see the history of dozens of revisions to the codes in Nevada, if not the content of the changes themselves:
I lived less than a mile from the hotel on that morning. I was a senior at UNLV and remember that day well. The whole day was chaos and the university opened their doors to the victims. It was a very sad day. It was very hard to believe that a fire like that could cause so much damage that quickly. So sorry for all the victims and their families. Almost 37 years ago.
As one who was involved in the investigation I read your article with great interest. I only wish you had given more attention to the positive impact the sprinkler system, where installed, had on the containment of the fire and probably preventing additional loss of life. In addition, I believe the contribution of the sprinkler system in the MGM fire has greatly contributed to not only industrial and commercial use and expansion of such systems. but residential use as well.
I remember waking up and turning on the TV and seeing some bearded guy climbing down ropes that had been dropped from the roof. I thought he was crazy…I was born and raised in Las Vegas and was 9 when the fire occurred. My friends dad was a captain in the fire department and what he saw haunted him. I remember the Hilton fire shortly after and how the news spent months on the issue. Those two fires changed Las Vegas for the better. From tragedy came reform and lives are safer for it.
Back in 2015, I stayed at this hotel — on the 22nd floor — and in a fit of morbid curiosity, I pulled up the 1980 MGM Fire Investigation Report to see if the room I was staying in was one of the victims’ rooms. The report mentioned that a couple of deaths on 22 occurred in the center stairwell due to the fact that the doors locked from the inside; and since this one particular stairwell had no roof access, once inside you were now committed to only going to the very bottom.
Because thick black acrid smoke was funnelling up the stairwells, anyone who entered and let the door close behind them were absolutely screwed. I took a peek into this very stairwell and was shocked to find out 25 years later these doors still lock from the inside; to this day, once you venture into the stairwell, you are trapped and must descend to the bottom. I propped the door open and took a little tour and discovered the only way out is at the very bottom where there is one emergency exit with one of those big red paddles you must push that activates an alarm. This is so stupid on a thousand levels. There are occasions where people have family or friends on adjacent floors and might just want to skip the elevator and walk up a flight. Perhaps someone might want to walk off that evening’s buffet slop and walk up 10 flights.
I mean, the elevators gave you free reign of the building, so it’s not like they’re worried about guests accessing other floors they “don’t belong on”, so what could be the official reason? How on earth are locked stairwell doors a safety measure and why do you suppose they insist on keeping it that way when those locks are the very thing that ended up killing people? If the official answer is “we don’t want smoke from the stairwells to fill the hallways” then they are basically saying “if you’re already in the stairwell and it’s full of smoke, too bad, no air for you, sucka!”
(PS: The stairwells at the residential tower unfortunately named “The Torch” in Dubai which caught fire recently have some sort of feature that somehow makes them fire and smoke-proof — so the technology apparently exists. Bally’s of all places could take notice of this..)
The second reading of the article and some of the comments is even more chilling.
I am returned.
I wish they would’ve included more history as to why this became Bally’s and when they rebuilt the now MGM grand. I’m very interested why they didn’t just keep the original site and re do it. But super interesting. Loved the story.
I wish they would’ve expanded on why it’s now Bally’s and why MGM is located elsewhere. Why didn’t they keep it there. But a very good article indeed.
There were two additional firefighters with those Illinois firefighters. Unfortunately, they stepped on an elevator not knowing a fire was raging below. Had an alarm sounded they would have most certainly avoided the elevator. Just really bad timing. :(
They were from my home town. I know some of their family